Saturday, December 17, 2011

Image Choice Implementation



I couldn't leave my kinders for winter break without VTSing one more time. So I slipped in my image selection for a feel good VTS kick.

Aside: The culture of the region I teach in is Protestant Christian. To the point that I have to discourage religious bullying in some of my upper grades. I thought this image was accessible to the students, but not evangelical. I myself am not christian, and  I do keep my religious persuasion out of the classroom. I chose this image because it would be easily read at some level even by young students - it is part of their visual culture.

I think I had posted earlier that I felt this image would be accessible to this age group because of the drama of the boo-boo. But I was very surprised by the meaning the students attached to this image. The first cause of surprise was the narrative that was formed. The dark clothing and the unhappy expression on the left figure's face gave one student the feeling that the boys in this painting were bad guys who were going to hurt the angel. Some other students added that the boys were taking the angel to a castle. One said the angel's head was about to be chopped off. There is a black horizontal line in the middle ground that crosses the stream and intersects with the angel's back. My kinders noticed this detail that I hadn't and three students said it was sticking out of the angel's back. One said it was the reason the angel was hurt, Two others said it was stuck into her back like a knife or a sword.

Not everyone interpreted the paining with the same meaning, though.  One person verbalized that they thought the boys were helping the angel by carrying her. Another student said that the angel's eyes were hurt. He also added that there was water in the flowers she is holding, and the water would help her eyes. This leads to discuss the level of logic that is becoming more evident with the kinders. Prior to the eye statement, a student had noticed that the flowers the angel was holding was similar to the flowers growing in the landscape behind her. (The boys had picked the flowers to give to her). Another point of interest was their discussion about directionality in the painting. Even though the students still don't address each other directly, there was disagreement about which way the stream flowed and how that affected the meaning. One person said the river was flowing from the ocean in the back to the bottom. Another addressed it later by saying he thought it was flowing up. During the discussion a person had said that the boys were trying to carry the angel to the river in the background so they could find a boat to get her some help. Another student said they couldn't be carrying her to the water because they were walking in the opposite direction. VTS lets me glimpse into their logic in a way I haven't seen in the past.

Now that we are at mid-year, the kinders are past their honeymoon period. There is a core group of students that I could VTS without distraction. But I have noticed that during our past few VTS sessions, there are students who ask, "We aren't going to make anything to day?" Which is kosher with me because kids come to art to "do." Also, kindergartners also have art for 20 minutes at a time. I reply that talking about art is just as important as doing, and that  I enjoy their discussions so much. Most of the students are eager to talk about art, though at the 8/9 minute mark I lose about 1/4 the class to fidgeting. The problem is, there are students who still want to talk about the artwork. Another quarter can stay focused during the disruptions and insist on keeping their hands up in the air. The other half can be swayed depending on their disposition to stay focused or be drawn into the playing. So I am ending this post with a question to all, In your opinion, how do I best manage the misbehaviors? I am O.K. with setting a timer for 10 minutes or less, and will try this first. But this caters to the fidgeters. How do I differentiate for those who are eager and are capable for a prolonged discussion? Independent writing is not an option because of their age.


AND ONE LAST THING: One of students offered evidence for her comment without being prompted. I was mentally in disbelief when it happened. She made a comment about the boys helping the angel and said it was because they were holding the poles and carrying her. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Summative Project

Here is the sculpture so far. My beginning concept was "layers," like in the layers of thinking a VTS facilitator has to do, and the layers and categories of audience that appear during a session. I wanted to incorporate movement into the sculpture. The figures you see in the video are on hinges, but most do not allow the figures to stand up on their own. I need to go back to the drawing board in the case of the hinges. I have also included some still images of Red Grooms work. When I was thinking of how to construct the figures, I kept thinking of Red Grooms' Ruckus Manhattan, because I have a very ruckus classroom. I was drawn by the caricatures, colors, and business of his work. The figures you see are snapshots of the students'  behaviors.  VTSing with these students has provided an education into their thinking and personalities that I would not see otherwise, for the most part.

At the time of this post, the plaster base is gone, gone to the dumpster. It still hasn't dried, and the marker from the bottom of the figures was starting to seep into the plaster. Most of the hinges have been removed also. My future plans for this work is creating more of an environment, and adding the other people who come in and out of the room during this class period.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

In Progress - Summative Project









Subway, 1971 by Red Grooms (lithograph)

So far, I have four students repoused, with another on the way this morning. I have narrowed my focus to the Nine who were post tested, plus myself. 


I am loosely basing my work on the installation Ruckus Manhattan by Red Grooms. I have pinpointed the use of facial expressions, gestures, motion and flat color to use in my final piece. I love Groom's caricatures, as well as his belief that art should be for everyone. His installations in the 70s were on the streets of New York, so anyone could experience the work at no cost.

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Blog #14


Student
Total Word Count
Total # Adjectives
Conditional Language
Assertions w/o Evidence
Questioning
Inference/Predictions
Emily
165 /40+
16/3
8/0
4/2
1/0
4/0
Elizabeth
58/20
4/1

3/0


Anna Grace
40/30+
2/0
2/0
3/0


Marlee
27/40+
1/0
1/1
2/ 1


Payton
111/75
6/1
1/1
9/2

2/2
Andrew
20/5
1/0
1/0
3/1


Jamison
67/50
7/2
0/1
2/2


Rayne
15/25
1/1

1/0


Daniel
30+/45
2/1
/2
5/5


 


Pre/Post VTS

I need to start out by saying that not all things were equal between the two assessments. During the pre-test, a smaller number of students were in the class, and two students were suspended. The post test included double the number of students. Also added to the mix was the fact that the students were wound up. About half of our VTS session was spent correcting misbehavior.
I do think that this class still belongs in the Level 1 viewer category. They like to describe and make up narratives.  The changes that I have observed during the post-test as follows:
  • Conditional language: I categorized ," I think that..." as conditional language for a kindergartner. The reason I did this is that I really think they were referencing their personal interpretations  in those statements. "I think.." statements were only made by one student during the pre-test. Most statements were, "That is..." During the post assessment there were more ,"I think" statements than, "That is."
  • Listing/matching - The pre-test was laden with listing and matching statements. The post- test included much more narrative and three statements about cause and effect. The students seemed to get past understanding the image and started to more comforable make connections that led to narratives.
  • Adjectives - no/ VERBS - Yes: I am listing a null change in the use of adjectives.  What I did notice was an increase in the use of verbs. During the pre-test the verbs were the obvious - skating, falling, snowing. During the post-test the students described slipping, running, dancing, spinning, and twisting. These verbs were added to their more developed narratives.
  • Accessibilty: The students still have a hard time figuring out overlapping shapes. Instead they find humor in pictures that juxtapose figures.

Interpreting the qualitative data. 
  • The advancement I viewed was related to the increase use of verbs when describing the artwork. The gestures and stop action poses really engaged the students and helped them to create narratives that were not evident during the pretest. Overall, the narrative and action in the artworks became expressed more in depth. I reference this development in a previous post comparing the VTS discussions between my four kindergarten classes. Using the same image, the class that consistently used VTS were able to read the image more successfully and become more engaged. They were able to go past describing behaviors in the initial viewing of the artwork, and make up many narratives. 
  • Perceived inaccuracies in in the artwork viewed triggers laughter, not disdain. They are not level 2 viewers yet.
  • I think that more research needs to be done into how language development of very young students both  is affected by and affects visual literacy. 
  • I think the VTS scoring guide needs to be modified to accurately can capture the developments in the kindergartners. I would recommend listing other categories to document the fluency with which students in this age group have in verbally describing art. I feel I need to research the literacy expectations of this grade level to more fully understand the data.
  • I would also recommend to future VTS teachers that  Piaget's stages of development need to be researched and incorporated into the findings at each viewing. It would give a general context to what the students are verbalizing.

Friday, November 11, 2011

VTS and 5th grade

I am using VTS for the first time with my fifth graders.  They discussed the image below after finishing a collage about popular culture. We are currently touching upon the Ashcan artists to pave the way for pop artists, who we will study for the rest of the year.  We start class by VTSing the image. I then give them a short excerpt to read from a Scholastic book which we discuss as a class. Then they look at the painting again and compare what they said during the VTS session with the information they read.  For the two classes that have done this so far, the students have made many connections with their initial observations and the class reading. It has been fun to hear the comments linking the two, and the comments have all been positive so far.

George Luks, Allen Street, 1905

The big differences between fifth grade and kindergarten have been 
  • Management: The older students don't wiggle and have better manners.
  • Linking: The fifth graders linked their comments to other students voluntarily during the initial VTS session
  • Evidence: after hearing me ask, "What do you see that makes you say that?"  twice, the students automatically started giving evidence
  • Personal experience: The fifth graders started their initial statements by saying, "I have been to a festival that looked like this, " or,  "I have been to an outdoor market."
  • Movement in the pictorial space: The students have experience with overlap and other levels of space, so it was easier for them to move around in the painting.

Blog #13

If only eating my own words was such a pleasant experience................

On the day I videotaped lesson 3, the internet was down. Which would have been fine, except I had not downloaded a big enough file for the image I wanted to VTS. As it were, I had a back up image already loaded into my Keynote presentation. I ended up VTSing a panel of Romare Bearden's The Block.  This image was already in slide format because I knew I was supposed to talk about it with all four of my kindergarten classes to support common core curriculum. I didn't want to use it for video #3 because I thought it would be a flop.  

As it turns out, it did produce limited conversation and interpretation with the other three classes. Each VTS session was 8-10 minutes long. My VTS class, though, talked for 20 minutes about the image.



Romare Bearden panel from The Block, 1971
Source: http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/1978.61.1-6


Critically evaluate the work of art you selected 

 In my previous post I stated " On one hand, the images are like a "Where's Waldo?" book. For a student that interested is in looking at an image for a long period of time, these pictures are eye candy. On the other hand, the concept of time between the artworks would be incomprehensible to a young child. I also think the comparing of two artworks in kindergarten is a bit much, since they are learning how to look at artwork. Both images lack in accessibility also. To understand the Breugel on even a surface level, one would need to know about rural life and the name of most of the objects in the painting. I think a lack of perquisite knowledge would prevent them from getting the overall feel of "community," even though  they would be fascinated with it. The Beardon has lots of colors, but it isn't easily readable.  Even on a large screen, the collaged black and white images are hard to see. The students would have to be right up to the image to see some of the figures. It would be hard to VTS. I think that both artworks, though interesting, may be better suited for a second grader who has the capacity to "read" an artwork or book."

Reflection
Based on Yenawine's guildelines for beginning viewers, I think this image was off because of the lack of personal experience this group of six year olds have had with the subject matter: big city life and a funeral. On the other hand, I knew most students attend church with their families and would recognize some of the religious images. They also know what cities are, though the community that feeds into this school does not have apartments - students live in houses, mobile homes, or multiple family homes. Also, given they are stage 1 viewers, they are open to art that isn't realistic, and don't pass judgment like a stage 2 viewer would. I do have two students that do list unrealistic characteristics of the images they discuss, and they find it funny.

I have contrasting results from my K VTS class and the other three K classes at the same school. In summary, the other classes that have only VTSed once before spent the discussion listing items they saw in the picture, such as rectangles, doors, people, buildings, and colors. A few students in these classes started narratives about the image, such as a person falling, and the people below were there to catch them. Out of these 3 classes, one student stated that the picture was of a city, and another student seemed to be figuring out movement in the space of the image, saying the people went in the door on the left and came out of the door on the right.
By comparison, the VTS class listed items less, and made more narratives. They listed actions such as a bomb exploding, a person in the door placing a bomb and running away, a robber, a robber pushing someone off the building and the crowd below would catch the person with a trampoline, etc. One student did state that he couldn't see the faces of the people in the picture, but I think this group was comfortable enough talking about artwork that the challenge was just right. There was a variety of opinions and stories offered, and the class discussion lasted 8 more minutes than it usually does!

Features of the artwork that the students focused on were the people, the angels, the large face in the upper right hand corner of a building, and people in the space of the stairs and doorways. They interpreted gestures of the figures, perhaps since they couldn't read the faces.

The surprise was that they were so intrigued by the image - I would have saved it for an older group of students.  If I were to VTS this image with kindergarten students again, it would be after the students had VTSed at least 6 times, so as to not frustrate a newbie who had very little experience looking at art and talking about it.

This is the project we are doing following the VTS session, to help them understand the type of image they were looking at.